Andi Madison Wagner: Dates, Accounts and a Search
A registry entry, a search flyer and original reporting preserve distinct kinds of evidence.
Abstract
NamUs MP94334 records August 6, 2022, as Andi Madison Wagner’s Date of Last Contact in Evansville, Indiana.1
A Case-Numbered Appeal
The registry identifies Evansville Police Department case 22-15858. Its narrative says being out of contact with family was unusual; that is the entry’s description, not a new family interview.1
A Texas EquuSearch flyer carries the same police case number and August 6 date. It describes a last-seen location in Evansville’s 3700 block of Stanford Drive.2
The flyer is a search organization’s appeal. Matching its case number helps connect the documents, but does not turn its short account into an inspected witness statement.2
Contact and Reporting
Kara Mattingly’s August 6, 2025, WFIE report gives August 12, 2022, as the family’s missing-person report date and August 6 as their last contact.3
Those dates describe different steps. The registry’s report-date field is empty; the later news account supplies a reported date rather than a second registry field.1,3
Confirmation and Speculation
WFIE’s May 7, 2024, story said authorities had not confirmed a connection between the Oakland City search and Wagner’s disappearance.4
Jill Lyman’s May 8 report then attributed confirmation to Evansville Police. It described three locations searched with the FBI and Indiana State Police after a tip, and material sent for laboratory testing.5
That sequence concerns what had been publicly confirmed at each publication time. A reported search is not, by itself, a finding about what happened to Wagner.
Sourced Accounts and Questions
Here’s where you come in. Can you find a dated account establishing the last contact and a separate record of the August 12 report?3
Can you identify what police confirmed on May 8, rather than carrying earlier speculation forward as a fact?4,5
Keep the flyer, dated reporting and unresolved questions in a Research File in Almost Solved. Record whose account each source attributes, and what remains unverified.
Show later developments and reported outcomes
Later Reporting
Mattingly’s August 6, 2025, anniversary report described the search as still unresolved at that time.3
This is a dated news update, not confirmation of Wagner’s whereabouts today. Later findings require their own source and date.
Scope and Method
Underlying police and laboratory records were not inspected. Dated reporting does not establish present circumstances.
Prepared with AI assistance. Sources and references checked against the cited public materials. This paper is an original synthesis of the identified public sources; it does not reproduce article bodies, transcripts, or an investigative file.
Footnote References
- NamUs, MP94334, Andi Madison Wagner; reviewed November 2, 2026.
- Texas EquuSearch, Andi Wagner flyer, police case 22-15858, undated; reviewed November 2, 2026.
- Kara Mattingly, WFIE, August 6, 2025, anniversary report; reviewed November 2, 2026.
- WFIE Staff, Oakland City search report, May 7, 2024; reviewed November 2, 2026.
- Jill Lyman, WFIE, Oakland City search confirmation, May 8, 2024; reviewed November 2, 2026.